RERUN
Claim 5

Receipt for run 1: the Lab's permanent record of what it did

Do better-looking professors get better student ratings?

RERUNCLAIM #0005

Do better-looking professors get better student ratings?

Measured in
rating points per point of looks
Paper says
0.275
Counts if
0.27 to 0.28
Lab got
0.2748
VerdictNumbers check out
d0b259198cc3c2ace78fNov 12, 2026

Paper said 0.275. We got 0.2748.

The code and data produced the same result. That doesn't prove the study's method is right.

Check this yourself

You don't have to trust us or the . With Docker and Node installed, this retraces the claim on your own computer and compares the number:

git clone <this repository> && cd rerun && pnpm install && pnpm sandbox:build
pnpm verify-claim 5

How much evidence is behind this?

Each step is a tougher test. Only the first one decides who wins the market.

  1. 1. ✓

    The Lab's retrace of the code and data named in the claim

    The Lab retraced the code and data and got a number inside the claim's range. YES wins.

  2. 2. –

    Stress test: does the number depend on luck?

    Fetching the extra runs…

  3. 3. –

    Rebuilt from the description (experimental)

    Fetching the AI's rebuild…

Coming next: a data-leakage check, for the same rows in training and test data, and a maths check on the statistics a paper reports. Neither has run on this claim.

Even all three steps can't prove the science is true. They show how well this result stands up to checking.

Verified

Your browser just re-checked these itself, so you don't have to trust this site.

Checking…

The write-up

The write-up isn't available right now. Its fingerprint is below.

The full record (technical)

✓ Verified on NEAR. See the contract's history

Outcome
REPRODUCED
d0b259198cc3c2ace78fbff438c2e074547728ad977b6141efd77f63b76c31dd
Commit
175eddea88cc8adab8dd20f2100b5b453d359244
Data fingerprints
a7d1d8e2a73259faed98ed6abbb3d396b2399c68e59ce6cfc6de94c736c9f1f6
Software versions fingerprint
8dab88328537f15c219ff04f4c55b0150f9867347067f4b5868ed8b0769249af
Runtime
1s, exit code 0
Started, finished
11/12/2026, 10:55:12 PM, 11/12/2026, 10:55:38 PM
Lab
lab.rerun-app.near
Lab code fingerprint
2eb776350ac7df5be3d241091996bd81238adc954a7ffbdb9ecea3870e2ae9bf
AI used
z-ai/glm-5.3-flash
6ae8a8550a54100e678c82dbce10fb9b1b570dc7dd2269213905227c08f6f713
Signed AI replies
016123e58af1456fbc152f491829ef57
Log fingerprint
2355db584fad3eaf8eb305351a9c9c957cc0e6c413455c0f16c0384a63f94296
Write-up fingerprint
f1bda7f7f9441891afee294cd26411dbb953c79cdfdd78319705a14ab061f4e7
Show the end of the run log
female -0.239
minority -0.249
non_native -0.253
tenure_track -0.136
lower_division -0.046
one_credit 0.687
looks_effect 0.2748